Sunday, September 23, 2012

Impact of Direct Marketing Activities on Company Reputation Transfer Success


Impact of Direct Marketing Activities on Company Reputation Transfer Success: Empirical Evidence from Five Different Cultures

Corporate Reputation Review (2010) 13, 20 – 37.doi: 10.1057/crr.2010.5
 
If a company specialized in hospital medical devices wants the clients to buy its new pharmaceutical products, how would the company successfully introduce the new product category with its existing brand name as a brand extension? It is not difficult for a company who has a favorable reputation. A peer reviewed hypothesis testing article presents direct marketing activities impact on reputation transfer. This article is important because the author provides empirical evidence on the significance of different cultural dimensions on companies' reputation, reputation transfer and brand extensions.
 
This article tested four different hypotheses. The first hypothesis is that " There is a positive relationship between the perceived fit of the new product range and the successful transfer of reputation in the pharmaceutical industry." The second hypothesis is that " Customer satisfaction has a strong, positive effect on reputation and is influenced by Word of Mouth(WOM)". The third hypothesis is that " Direct marketing media have a substantial impact on company reputation and reputation transfer". The fourth hypothesis is that "The impact of different cultural dimensions on the reputation construct is expected to differ significantly among the surveyed countries". The surveyed countries are Germany, Finland, Spain, Russia, and Australia, all with different scores on culture differences in the categories: Individualism vs Collectivism, Masculinity vs Femininity, Power distance and Uncertainty avoidance (all the aspects are part of Hofstede's cultural dimensions). The direct marketing activities included fairs, symposia, visits of sales representatives, brochures, internet and mailings. The paper studies the impact of culture on purchase behavior of consumers of pharmaceutical products.
 
The result of this study shows that the perceived fit of new products to the existing product range has substantial impact on reputation transfer in feminine countries rather than masculine countries. The perceived fit can significantly enhance company's reputation. The reputation is also highly impacted by personal recommendations of product through word of mouth and customer satisfaction in collectivist countries. Additionally, the influence of company's reputation is significant for the countries with high power distance and high masculinity scores.
 
Culture environment differs from country to country, practicing executives and managers should know how to adjust the direct marketing activities by matching different culture to generate good reputation in international marketing.

 

4 comments:

  1. The fourth hypothesis reminds me of what I learned in a course on global environment of business - there are many different cultural aspects one needs considers. Which of the four hypothesis best provides for innovative marketing concepts that executives should keep in mind when fielding new products?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All four of the hypotheses are extremely relevant when you are looking at innovative marketing options when fielding a new product. I agree with that there are many different cultural aspects you will have to take into account, but at the same time you cannot generalize culture aspects into different categories so to do that would take an in-depth study of each individual country/case. So for each different country, one or two of the hypotheses will be more important than others. Simply, the answer will be different in every case.

      Delete
  2. I was wondering the same thing regarding marketing these products in a global environment. It appears that by fitting marketing strategy to a particular region's "cultural dimensions", a firm would increase its chances of success as compared to another firm using a "shotgun" approach in their marketing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shotgun option would hinder the marketing efforts in countries with different cultural dimensions according to this article. Instead of generalizing the marketing effort, tailoring the techniques to fit individual culture backgrounds seems to be the more effective method.

      Delete